About Us  |   Advertise  |   Contact Us  |   Terms & Conditions  |   RSS Feeds
deposit rates

Blue Star's bondholders face a nasty choice

Blue Star Group's bondholders are being offered a nasty choice between the near certainty of losing all their money or holding on to a slim chance of being repaid a small part of it in three year's time.


Monday, 18 July 2011

by Jenny Ruth

The NZX-listed bonds have a face value of $105 million. Since interest payments were suspended in August 2009, a further $32.3 million in interest has accrued.

The proposal they are being asked to vote for on August 10 would see the net present value of their investment reduced to $44 million, just over a third of its current face value, but that's only if everything proceeds as directors propose.


Bondholders would have to write off their $32.3 million of accrued interest immediately.


The earliest they would see any actual cash is on October 15, 2013 when they would be paid interest at the rate of 9.1% from July 15, 2013 on $67.5 million face value. Between now and then, Blue Star's bankers won't allow it to pay interest to bondholders. The bonds are currently accruing interest at 13.1%.


The other $37.5 million of bonds will be converted to "participating bonds," or effectively equity on which no interest is payable and which have a September 15, 2023 maturity date.


To get this second part of their money back, investors have to hope the business can be sold for a large enough sum to repay them.


The only realistic alternative, according to directors, is insolvency in which case bondholders are unlikely to receive anything.


Independent expert accounting firm KPMG concluded that while management forecasts are "realistic," it can provide no assurance the forecasts will be achieved.


"Recent performance has indicated that the group is continuing to experience difficult trading conditions," KPMG says, citing the impact of the Christchurch earthquake and commissioning costs of a new plant in Auckland.


"If trading conditions continue to deteriorate, this will impact on the group's ability to achieve its financial forecasts," KPMG says. Failing to meet those forecasts could lead to default of Blue Star's banking agreement and could send it into receivership anyway with bondholders receiving nothing.


Even if everything does go to plan, KPMG doesn't think bondholders will get even the written down value of their money back. "The likely outcome is that the level of repayment will be low relative to the face value of the interest bearing bondsand there is unlikely to be any repayment on the participating bonds."


Blue Star's track record to date doesn't inspire confidence. Back in 2005 when the bonds were being sold, director Tom Sturgess was confidently predicting Blue Star would buy back the bonds long before maturity at 103.5% of their face value.


Sturgess and Australian private equity firm CHAMP own 93.7% of Blue Star.


Comments from our readers

On 20 July 2011 at 12:37 am Mike said:
This deal is no deal. I will be against this proposal. I would rather go to receivership than let the management continue on. The bondholders are the only ones that are taking a haircut. Champ and the banks are not taking any losses at all. This deal is not acceptable. It is in fact a farce.
On 23 July 2011 at 5:19 pm Trevor said:
I agree. Under this proposal the value of our investment will be drastically reduced while the major shareholder (CHAMP) will move ahead of the bond holders for any payout when Blue Star is sold or goes into liquidation.
Commenting is closed


Printable version


Email to a friend
Newsletter Signup

Weekly Updates including news and commentary

Today's Best Bank Rates
Rabobank 0.75
Based on a $50,000 deposit    More Rates »
Today's Top 5 Deposit Rates
NZCU Auckland 1.00 Success Saver
First Credit Union 0.75 Online Savings
Rabobank 0.75 Rabobank PremiumSaver - max rate
Heretaunga Building Society 0.60 On Call
NZCU Baywide 0.60 Success Saver
Based on a $50,000 deposit    More Rates »
Find a Rate
Show me the rates for
invested over
Use the full calculator
Cash PIE Rates
Institution Rate 30% 33%
ANZ 0.10 0.10 0.11
ASB Bank 0.15 0.16 0.17
ASB Bank 0.15 0.16 0.17
ASB Bank 0.15 0.16 0.17
ASB Bank 0.15 0.16 0.17
ASB Bank 0.15 0.16 0.17
BNZ 0.10 0.10 0.10
Heartland Bank 0.40 0.40 0.40
Kiwibank 0.05 - -
Kiwibank 0.25 - -
Nelson Building Society - - -
SBS Bank - - -
TSB Bank 0.25 0.25 0.26
Westpac 0.20 0.21 0.23
Westpac 0.05 0.05 0.05
Westpac 0.25 0.26 0.27

More »

Previous News
Latest Trends
Coming Soon

Disclaimer - Every possible effort has been made to keep the information in the tables and on this site as accurate as possible, however, neither the publisher, Tarawera Publishing, nor anyone engaged to compile the rates and this site accept any liability for inaccuracies or any loss suffered as a result. It is strongly advised that readers check loan details with providers. The full terms and conditions of this site can be found here.

© Copyright 1997-2021. Tarawera Publishing Ltd. All Rights Reserved.